costume jewelry

Where to Sell Your Costume Jewelry: A Guide for Every Treasure

Costume jewelry – those beautiful, eye-catching pieces that add a touch of personality to any outfit – can accumulate over time. Maybe your tastes have changed, or you’ve inherited a collection you don’t wear. Whatever the reason, you might be considering selling your costume jewelry. But with so many options available, where do you even begin?

This comprehensive guide will walk you through the various avenues for selling your costume jewelry, helping you find the best fit for your needs and the type of pieces you have.

Considering Value: Vintage vs. Modern

The first step is to assess the value of your costume jewelry. Here’s a crucial distinction: vintage versus modern.

  • Vintage Costume Jewelry: Pieces from a specific era, typically pre-1980s, can hold significant value, especially if they’re from renowned designers or feature unique materials. Look for hallmarks or designer signatures to determine authenticity. Popular vintage costume jewelry brands include Coro, Trifari, and Sarah Coventry.

  • Modern Costume Jewelry: While modern pieces may not fetch the same prices as vintage ones, they can still sell well, particularly if they’re on-trend or in good condition. Consider the overall quality of the materials and construction.

Where to Sell Your Costume Jewelry: A Guide for Every Treasure插图

Choosing Your Selling Platform

Once you have a general idea of your jewelry’s value, you can explore the different selling platforms. Here are some popular options, each with its own advantages and considerations:

Online Marketplaces:

  • eBay: A long-standing online marketplace, eBay caters to a wide audience of collectors and casual buyers. You can set a fixed price or hold auctions, offering flexibility in how you sell your pieces. However, fierce competition can sometimes lead to lower selling prices. Photography and detailed descriptions are crucial for success on eBay.

  • Etsy: An excellent platform for selling vintage and handmade items, Etsy attracts a niche audience of vintage enthusiasts. If your costume jewelry has a unique story or historical significance, Etsy could be a perfect fit.

  • Poshmark: This social commerce platform is ideal for selling modern, trendy costume jewelry. Poshmark fosters a community-driven experience, allowing you to share listings and build a following.

Direct Selling Platforms:

  • Facebook Marketplace: A convenient way to reach local buyers, Facebook Marketplace allows you to post photos and descriptions of your jewelry. It facilitates direct communication with potential buyers, but the reach might be limited compared to national online platforms.

  • Craigslist: Similar to Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist offers local selling opportunities. Be cautious of scams and ensure you meet buyers in a safe, public place.

costume jewelry

Brick-and-mortar Options:

  • Consignment Shops: These stores sell pre-owned items for a commission. They handle marketing and pricing, taking some of the work off your plate. However, the commission can significantly reduce your final profit. Research reputable consignment shops specializing in vintage clothing or accessories to find the best fit for your jewelry.

  • Pawn Shops: Pawn shops might be an option for selling costume jewelry quickly, but they typically offer low prices. This option might be best if you need to sell your jewelry fast and don’t prioritize maximizing your profit.

costume jewelry

Maximizing Your Sales Potential

No matter which platform you choose, here are some tips to increase your chances of selling your costume jewelry for a good price:

  • High-Quality Photos: Investing in clear, well-lit photos showcasing your jewelry from multiple angles is essential. Capture details like clasps, materials, and any unique features.

  • Detailed Descriptions: Write accurate descriptions highlighting the materials, size, condition, and any distinguishing marks of your jewelry. Mention the era if you believe it’s vintage.

  • Competitive Pricing: Research similar pieces on the chosen platform to set a fair price. Consider the condition, brand (if applicable), and current market trends.

  • Honesty and Transparency: Be upfront about any flaws or damage in your descriptions. Building trust with potential buyers is key.

Where to Sell Your Costume Jewelry: A Guide for Every Treasure插图3

Additional Tips for Specific Types of Jewelry

  • Vintage Costume Jewelry: Research designer signatures and hallmarks to identify valuable pieces. Emphasize the history and provenance of your vintage finds in your descriptions.

  • Large Costume Jewelry Collections: Consider selling a curated collection as a set to attract serious buyers. This can be a good option for vintage pieces with a cohesive style.

  • Costume Jewelry Sets: Selling necklaces, earrings, and bracelets as a set can be more appealing to buyers than selling individual pieces.

Where to Sell Your Costume Jewelry: A Guide for Every Treasure插图4

Write detailed product descriptions

Art Deco Emerald Elegance Necklace (For Etsy)

Headline: Dazzling Deco Dreams: Emerald Green Glass Necklace with Chandelier Crystals


Transport yourself to the glamour of the 1920s with this exquisite Art Deco necklace. Featuring a central emerald green glass cabochon, this captivating piece evokes the opulence of the era. Delicate silver-plated chains cascade down, adorned with sparkling clear crystals that shimmer like chandelier droplets. The perfect finishing touch for any vintage-inspired outfit, this necklace is sure to turn heads.


  • Era: Vintage (estimated 1920s-1930s)
  • Materials: Emerald green glass cabochon, silver-plated chains, clear crystals
  • Length: 18 inches (adjustable with lobster claw clasp)
  • Condition: Excellent vintage condition with minimal signs of wear.


Imagine yourself attending a Gatsby-esque soiree, adorned in this captivating necklace. The emerald green hue adds a touch of sophistication, while the cascading crystals capture the light with a mesmerizing brilliance. This piece is a true heirloom, waiting to add a touch of vintage magic to your jewelry collection.

Statement Chunky Gold Hoop Earrings (For Poshmark)

Headline: Major Hoop Energy: Bold Gold Statement Earrings for Trendsetters


Elevate your everyday look with these on-trend chunky gold hoop earrings. Crafted from a lightweight, hypoallergenic alloy, these statement hoops offer bold style without weighing down your ears. The sleek, polished gold finish adds a touch of luxury to any outfit, making them perfect for dressing up a casual tee or adding edge to a formal dress.


  • Material: Hypoallergenic alloy with gold finish
  • Diameter: 2 inches
  • Closure: Secure click-on clasp

Keywords: chunky hoops, gold hoops, statement earrings, hypoallergenic earrings, on-trend jewelry

Mismatched Vintage Charm Bracelet (For Online Marketplace)

Headline: One-of-a-Kind: Mismatched Vintage Charm Bracelet with Quirky Character


This unique vintage charm bracelet is a conversation starter waiting to happen! Featuring a collection of mismatched charms from different eras, this piece celebrates individuality and self-expression. From a whimsical teapot charm to a lucky horseshoe, each charm tells a story and adds a touch of whimsy. Crafted from a mix of silver and gold-toned metals, this bracelet is perfect for layering with other pieces or making a bold statement on its own.


  • Era: Mixed vintage charms (estimated 1950s-1980s)
  • Materials: Mixed metals (silver and gold-toned)
  • Length: 7 inches (adjustable with lobster claw clasp)
  • Condition: Good vintage condition with some minor wear consistent with age.

Keywords: vintage charm bracelet, mismatched charms, quirky jewelry, statement bracelet, unique jewelry

Selling costume jewelry can be a rewarding experience, allowing you to declutter, make some extra cash, and potentially find a new home for cherished pieces. By carefully considering the value of your jewelry and choosing the right platform, you can maximize your chances of a successful sale. Remember, presentation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *